The Nashville perspective

Seller concessions: measure the reported dollars and the missing records

A concession study needs a defined numerator, a disclosed denominator and a separate missing-data count. An unfilled field does not prove the seller contributed nothing.

How missing records change an apparent rate

In a hypothetical set of 100 closings, 30 show a positive concession, 50 show a recorded zero and 20 are blank. The rate is 37.5% among 80 known records. Across all closings, 30% have a recorded positive amount. Both can be reported with labels; they answer different questions.

Record groupCount
Positive amount30
Explicit zero50
Unknown or blank20
Positive among known30 ÷ 80 = 37.5%

Keep assistance categories distinct

Capture closing-cost assistance, repair credits and other incentives separately when the source supports that distinction. Do not infer a lender-approved credit from an MLS remark. Financing programs and actual loan documents determine usable amounts. Publish the median positive concession separately from an average across all known records, because zeros change the interpretation.

Report two denominators for concessions

Show the total number of eligible closed records and the smaller number with a usable concession field. Calculate the observed concession rate among usable records, then explain how missing entries limit any statement about the full cohort. Keep a dollar amount separate from a rate buydown or repair agreement unless the source documentation defines how those items are recorded.

Sources & further reading

  1. CFPB determine a comfortable home budget checked 2026-09-26

Your next chapter

Let’s make it
a good move.

Bring your questions. Start a conversation with Gary’s team.

Discuss your next move